Made a spreadsheet for Melee WP weapons/armor sets

It's not totally pretty, but helps us figure out what armor pieces are best at what stage as well as what weapons are best.

I'm not sure how to host it here, but if you email me (under my profile) or reply to this thread, I'll send you the excell spreadsheet I made. Moradan I know you'd probably like this. From what weight I gave various stats, Onslaught is actually #2 or #3 weapon despite not having +melee crit on it (for example).

» Edited on: 2009-11-18 06:34:43

Note: Just a heads up, this is only for a WP. Though if you ask super nicely, I can do it for other classes as well. Just let me know what armor set combo's you want me to compare and set up in excel for you.

» Edited on: 2009-11-20 22:08:20

I would like it for sure. I am at work right now, but if you can email it to me with the email under my profile that would be great. Other wise i'll talk to you later when I am online.

I'd like a copy too, send it to my e-mail as well please.

K I've sent it to four folks. Let me know what you guys think and what improvements (either in gear setup) or in excel coding I can do.

I'd like a copy too if you don't mind

Not bad conversion of one of my tabs.

» Edited on: 2009-11-23 17:41:07

Too bad I use a one hander... got any info for us non melee types? :) Currently my one hander stinks, I would love to see a comparison of them so I could figure out where I might to need to focus my efforts to get a good weapon and book. Dahbit

Sure I can do a comparison of 1H healing weps. Do you like how much weight I give stats? I'll do something similar if so.

K made one for both 1H healing hammers and the off-hand books. I'll send it to Don and he can post it in this thread like he did the 2h hammers. EDIT: Also gave crits more weight. They didn't seem to give as much punch as they needed to.

» Edited on: 2009-11-24 11:47:42 EDIT: Talked to Gimba, crit of any kind needs a weight of 20, not 1 or 5. Adjust your spreadsheets accordingly.

» Edited on: 2009-11-24 15:12:50