Well... I'd disagree with you there, Elth, but I'm not looking to get into a debate. :)
I don't expect most people to be in character, but seeing character names that don't rip me out of immersion is something that's very very important to me, and when I left Trion wasn't enforcing their so-called RP-server rules at all. Faeblight was just like any other server in that regard. I moved to Argent, the EU RP server, and the difference was like night and day -- polite people, and not one non-RP name, that I saw.
But I missed Gaiscioch, and then Trion had to make the wardrobe system so half-assed (compared to the one in LotRO), and I was very angry and disappointed. The rage has dissipated now. :P
I've rolled up a new character and I have to say that just from playing a few hours it does look better now than it was, certainly.